With reference to Kerry Kennedy’s article entitled ‘A liberal mind’ in the
‘South China Morning Post’ dated October 30, I would like to express my point
of view about the importance of developing genuine citizenship.
Genuine citizenship is what students need to be educated on as it is a key
factor in the well being of the city. This is particularly true at these
particular times when the Occupy Central movement is making a huge impact on
the lives of the Hong Kong residents. The protesters may consider themselves
striving for a worthy cause, trying to make a difference to the future of Hong
Kong. However, as caring citizens, they ought to be aware of their
responsibilities and cannot turn a deaf ear to the complaints their courses of
action have led to. What they are doing would be worth nothing, however lofty
an ideal it may seem, if many are made to pay the high cost of it.
As mentioned in Kerry Kennedy’s article, students ought to learn to be
‘literate citizens, not single-issue citizens looking for quick fixes to
complex problems’. The protesters need to have a good understanding of the
electoral arrangements for the Chief Executive Election as an issue too complex
to deal with speedily. It is necessary, too, to evaluate different sources of
information related to the issue and to view it from various perspectives.
While making their own judgment about the issue, they should also be willing to
consider other solutions apart from the one they abide by.
We have seen on TV how the protesters’ representatives negotiated with the
government officials. We appreciate their confidence and sincerity. But we
would also like to see them more enlightened and equipped with better skills to
speak convincingly while at the same time showing tolerance of opponent points
of view over areas of disagreement. This, as Kerry Kennedy suggests, is what is
expected of democratic citizens.
Last but not least, students should learn to be law-abiding citizens as a
city's well being depends on the citizens' respect for and adherence
to law. Anything students do should be within the law. Refusal to comply
with the injuncture issued by the court of law is a serious breach of law that
should be condemned.
In brief, I see genuine citizenship as a requisite for democracy and
social involvement. Students ought to be trained to be intelligent and caring
citizens if they aspire to contribute to a democratic society.
Civil disobedience by definition violates the law, but it's a legitimate way to express one's grievance against a sham government with unjust laws.
回覆刪除Thank you for your comment, Teacher. There are obviously areas over which our opinions differ. But we remain on friendly terms. Mutual respect among people and tolerance of alternate points of view are elements of a democratic society. And for this democracy is aadvocated. What I'm asking for is harmony in the community with people showing respect for one another.
回覆刪除And for this democracy is advocated.
回覆刪除I agree with all that stuff about respect and tolerance in a democracy, once it's achieved. But the rules on respect and tolerance may be different when one is on the path towards democracy....something about "growing pains"... :-)
刪除Something similar to labour pain previous to child delivery ? Well, I think I understand.
回覆刪除haha, i like your analogy of labor pains better, much better...
刪除